How Much Does Insurance Increase After An Accident

Navigating the aftermath of an auto accident can be daunting, especially when it comes to understanding how it affects your car insurance premiums. An at-fault accident typically leads to an increase in auto insurance rates, but the extent of this increase varies based on several factors, including your state, insurer, and the specifics of the accident.

State Average Rate Increase (%)
Alabama 55%
Alaska 46%
Arizona 53%
Arkansas 67%
California 68%
Colorado 43%
Connecticut 60%
Delaware 38%
Florida 49%
Georgia 60%
Hawaii 41%
Idaho 46%
Illinois 52%
Indiana 63%
Iowa 40%
Kansas 46%
Kentucky 58%
Louisiana 62%
Maine 55%
Maryland 56%
Massachusetts 58%
Michigan 49%
Minnesota 42%
Mississippi 67%
Missouri 54%
Montana 44%
Nebraska 51%
Nevada 51%
New Hampshire 54%
New Jersey 92%
New Mexico 40%
New York 38%
North Carolina 67%
North Dakota 43%
Ohio 57%
Oklahoma 51%
Oregon 58%
Pennsylvania 72%
Rhode Island 4%
South Carolina 44%
South Dakota 38%
Tennessee 57%
Texas 71%
Utah 55%
Vermont 41%
Virginia 52%
Washington 49%
West Virginia 52%
Wisconsin 57%
Wyoming 36%

This chart provides a general overview of how much car insurance rates can increase on average in each state following an at-fault accident. Keep in mind that these percentages are subject to change and may not reflect the most current data. It’s always a good idea to consult with insurance providers for the most accurate and up-to-date information.

The Financial Implications of At-Fault Accidents

On average, drivers with a recent at-fault accident pay $1,016 more annually for a full coverage policy compared to those with a clean driving record. This rate hike is influenced by factors such as the driver’s location, the insurance company, and the severity of the accident. For instance, in states like Michigan, Florida, New Jersey, and Texas, average rates can surge by more than $1,500 per year post-accident.

State Variations and Insurance Company Policies

Each state has its own regulations affecting how much insurance rates can increase after an accident. For example, in Washington, D.C., and most states except Rhode Island, average annual rates are over $500 higher for drivers with a recent at-fault accident. In 10 states, these rates can spike by at least 50% post-accident.

Insurance companies also play a crucial role in determining rate increases. Companies like State Farm, Allstate, Progressive, and Geico, which make up a significant portion of the market, have different policies regarding rate hikes after accidents. State Farm often offers the lowest average rates for drivers post-accident, while other companies may double the rates.

Strategies to Mitigate Rate Increases

  1. Shop Around for Better Rates: After an accident, it’s wise to compare car insurance rates from various providers. Smaller insurance companies sometimes offer lower rates than the big names in the industry.
  2. Consider Accident Forgiveness Programs: Some insurers offer accident forgiveness policies, either as a paid option or as a reward for safe driving, which can prevent your rates from increasing after your first at-fault accident.
  3. Improve Your Credit Score: A better credit score can lead to more favorable insurance rates in most states.
  4. Increase Your Deductible: Opting for a higher deductible can lower your premium, but it means more out-of-pocket expenses in case of another accident.
  5. Look for Discounts: Always check for any additional discounts you may be eligible for with your insurance provider.

The Role of No-Fault Accidents

Even if you’re not at fault, your insurance premium might still increase, especially if your insurer has to cover your claim. This is more common in no-fault states, where each party involved in an accident files a claim with their own insurer for injuries.


Understanding how at-fault accidents impact your auto insurance rates is crucial for financial planning and risk management. By exploring options like shopping around, leveraging accident forgiveness, and improving credit scores, drivers can find ways to manage increased premiums. Remember, each situation is unique, and the best approach depends on individual circumstances, state laws, and specific insurance company policies.

    FREE Case Evaluation

    Speak To A Lawyer Now!